Nicolo Rizzuto, a reputed Mafia don, was given a Roman Catholic funeral in Montreal, known as a Mass of Christian Burial, but the church has in the past denied mobsters’ funerals.The church’s code of conduct states that “manifest sinners” cannot be given a funeral mass if it would result in public scandal of the faithful. It’s been a dicey dilemma for Catholic leaders in the past: to agree, or not to agree, to provide a church funeral for a well-known gangster?
The church has occasionally refused such rites to Rizzuto’s counterparts in the past under a set of guidelines that provide it with considerable interpretive leeway. One Catholicism expert states that under the church’s Code of Canon Law, Mafia dons could be denied a funeral ceremony. In the past, church officials have decided against holding Catholic funerals for other mob leaders, including John Gotti and Paul Castellano. Both Gotti, who died in 2002, and Castellano, killed in 1985, were former heads of the notorious Gambino crime family. Gotti ordered Castellano killed and was linked to other murders.
“One would think that that may raise a question mark,” McGill University’s Daniel Cere stated, pointing to the world of organized crime. Rizzuto, on the other hand, was convicted of several crimes, including gangsterism, and his clan is suspected of killing many rivals over the years. But he was never convicted of murder. Cere stated the church tends to have a loose interpretation of the funeral guidelines unless the deceased has formally repudiated the Catholic faith. “My impression is that the church has been reluctant to get into debates,” the religious studies professor stated. “It would probably be a bit messy if they started to try to provide tighter criteria in terms of denial of funerals, so I think they tend to take a fairly relaxed attitude towards the issue.” When the decision whether to permit, or disallow a funeral ceremony is up for debate, Cere states the local bishop has the final call.
Under canon law, there are three categories for refusing to provide a Catholic funeral. Someone could be denied a funeral unless they gave, before dying, some sign of repentance for the following:
— Being notorious apostates, heretics and schismatics.
— Choosing the cremation of their bodies for reasons contrary to Christian faith.
— Being manifest sinners who could not be granted ecclesiastical funerals without public scandal of the faithful.
“It looks like there’s a lot of leeway in all of these,” stated Cere. He added that canon law is a collection of guiding principles, not absolute rules.